Where to begin? I'll start by saying that this novel stayed in my to read shelf for about 6 months before I actually pulled the trigger. I am an AVID reader of old school rewrites so I wanted to give it a fair shake even though the reviews were pretty all over the place. I wasn't disappointed, but as someone who is a serious lover of all things Wizard of Oz related, I felt it could be better.
What I liked:
The concept was fabulous. Wicked Dorothy. Wicked Galinda (notice I used the "Wicked" spelling). Sounded like a match made in heaven for me.
Old characters from the other Oz novels making their way into the books.
What was the last book you read? Have you checked out this series?
What I didn't like:
Amy in general. I just didn't love her. She seems to just HAVE to do the opposite of everything she was told.
Dorothy wasn't evil enough. I expected some serious evil shit. I thought she was going to be chopping off fingers and popping out eyeballs. The novellas that went along with the story line were actually really good. There was more violence and murdering. But I had to remind myself that this is a YA (very YA) novel. Which leads me to my second point.
The writing was too YA for me. That's sounds so ridiculous doesn't it. This is no reflection on the author. It is clearly a book for young adults, but it's a little too basic for my tastes. I like more creative language. I like when I have to go to the dictionary to clarify.
Imagery was lacking. There were a few times when Amy "couldn't find the words to describe" what she was seeing. That felt like a cop out to me. I wanted, yearned for, that description. It's funny because I'm reading the short novellas and they are much more vivid. I didn't feel like I had a picture of the scene because of the lack of details.
Update: I've read all three of the novellas and The first two were pretty good. That last one left something to be desired. I have just downloaded "The Wicked will Rise" and I will update with my thoughts on it.